The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt contains upwards of 100 quests - and that's only the named ones. Then continue following Johnny and proceed as usuall with everything else. Imperial Audience - Tips And Best Answers. Regardless, the tree will exact revenge on the village of Downwarren. 3) Release tree spirit before other quest - village attacked, Anna lives but mad, Baron lives, kids dead. You can choose to free, kill or deceive the spirit, and each choice has consequences for the story and the world. Quests like 'The Whispering Hillock' show that the world contained within is actually pretty grim. The Ghost in the Tree is a creature in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. . The Whispering Hillock is pretty much our last required stop for this visit to Velen; it will wrap up Family Matters as well as the entire Velen sequence of the In Ciri's Footsteps quest. The mother fucking Whispering Hillock this arguably has to be the hardest decision in the entire game for me. the wife didn't go insane and 3 members of the family left together. You free the spirit, the orphans are saved, Anna dies, Bloody Baron commits suicide. 10: Talk. The Whispering Hillock;In the Witcher 3 you’ll gain XP via the following: Killing enemies, Progressing through story events; Completing secondary-quests and Witcher Contracts. The Whispering Hillock: The Fate Of The Orphans, The Town of Downwarren, and Anna. These quests include The Whispering Hillock, Family Matters, and Ladies of the Wood. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt Walkthrough Team. And I do see your point. 19. Over time, the Lady began to go mad, causing Velen to fall into destruction, and so the daughters killed their mother and buried her in the bog. Also, if you read the book "She Who Knows" in the game it pretty clearly points out that the spirit in the whispering hillock is the Crones mother, the Lady of the Woods. Use Witcher Senses to find three clues inside the bedroom. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt . The Whispering Hillock is one of. My Ciri cosplay from The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt! I hope you`ll like it!SPOILERS, A question about doing "The Whispering Hillock" early. 1. Good riddance. Vesemir: Pretend now, live later! Riposte. I looked up ways to fix this and have tried several things such turning off/on V-sync, changing framerate, lowering settings, changing the screen mode. The Whispering Hillock - You will receive this quest from the Witches in the Crookback Bog (M9,17). Many winding paths lead to the Oak from all. 10. But yeah I also prefer the kill the spirit option. The Whispering Hillock: Ancient Oak 5 17 Ciri's Story: Fleeing the Bog: Crookback Bog 5 18 Pyres of Novigrad: Novigrad 10 19 Novigrad. Attempting to murder a child unless your ex returns to you is deeply deeply evil. Use your Witcher Sense to find a grave at the southern part of the marker and loot it. In this video I delve into the Whispering Hillock, or the Ghost in the Tree. Dedlaw • 1 yr. You encounter the Whispering Hillock on your own, before the Crones mention it. You free the Spirit, and it then ravages Downwarren. The nature of this spirit is not fully explained. Ozymandias Jan 4, 2018 @ 11:33pm. Also a couple of afterm. Anna dies and the Baron kills himself. Witcher 3 Ladies Of The Wood Conversation Options . free the spirit: the village of Downwarren is attacked, the orphans are freed, the Crones put a curse on Anna and transform her into a water hag, the baron commits suicide. The 2 options are. I think you probably didn't agree to help the baron, and hence didn't complete the ending. It switches back and forth a couple times, but for the majority of the quest, its the "nicer" Geralt. There's a way to save Anna by doing the tree out of sequence, but I don't remember exactly if it was killing the tree or setting it free that got Anna cursed. the wife didn't go insane and 3 members of. Albin will ask Geralt to defend him and his men. Proceed to the gnarled-looking tree and activate your Witcher Senses. as well as casually trying to shoehorn in The Witcher 3 articles wherever possible. Boards. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt > General Discussions > Topic Details. The baron goes away either way and his wife is either dead or mental. No whispers, endregas everywhere, can't interact with the spirit/plant. If you have a torch equipped to see better, remove it. 0). Return to Crookback Bog is a secondary quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt which occurs right after Geralt of Rivia agrees to help the Bloody Baron reclaim his wife, Anna. During the Whsipering Hillock part of the questchain, Geraly will have a decision to make, which will come back to haunt the bloody baron in one way or another. It can be found relatively often as random loot, but it is also scripted to appear in the southeastern hut at Heatherton, and in two spots around the sabbath village during the main quest, Bald Mountain - on a cabinet. Later, I did the Ladies quest and freed the spirit. You get confirmation of that later in the game. I already talked to the spirit bit was unsure if I should release him or kill him, so I searched online and found a page that says the way I dealt with the spirit would interfere in the. Can anyone screenshot me where it is or link me to a map that has the info? Thanks a ton, as I've been unable to find it. The Witcher 3’s quests are riddled with decisions that can change how the quest or even the future story progresses and which possible ending you get for the game. I finally started The Witcher 3 and I’ve started a gaming journal to chronicle the adventure!Marabella was a teacher at her "School for Tots" in Novigrad in 1272 and one of Dandelion's former pupils. Contents The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. She Who Knows is a book in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, describing a legend of the Ghost in the Tree from a perspective favoring the Crones' image as benevolent deities of Velen. The best choice for Whispering Hillock is to free the "evil" spirit. Most of the time they communicate through an enchanted tapestry and a medium, an elderly woman named Gran who also. 9: After calling for Johnny, use your Witcher Senses to find his footprints. After finishing The Calm. Read up that it was part of another quest and so I said I would think about freeing it or not. The identity of this individual - once known as the Lady of the Wood - is a myst. In this video the Witcher becomes a horse Whisperer as he tries to ""Calm a Wild Horse Using the Axii sign and mount it" and then has to "Bring a black wild. Dip into the water straight ahead And swim around the obstruction in the cave, using your Witcher Senses underwater to pinpoint and loot three chests found below. The next part of The Witcher 3's story can begin, and you are free to enter the city of Novigrad or the distant shores of Skellige. It will end with a shawl stuck to a tree. The spirit's presence has. Video with: Dead kid above Whispering Hillock Cave and asking the Tree spirit about it - Witcher 3 ️ If you want, you can support by becoming Member ️ :been a while since I played that quest though, so I don't remember exactly where the new cave opening is. But the Baron, Anna and the village dies. Jun 27, 2017. Vase of Flowers. It is possible to complete "The Whispering Hillock" in several different ways, each of which will affect "Return to Crookback Bog" differently. Note: this quest will fail if not completed before starting The Isle of Mists. After speaking to the ealdorman head to the southeast towards the Whispering Hillock. 2. This is one of those quests that has an impact on the rest of the story and is much more interesting if completed during the main quest and not performed as a side quest. Here are a few of the most vital. 6 The Whispering Hillock. She Who Knows is a book in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, describing a legend of the Ghost in the Tree from a perspective favoring the Crones' image as benevolent deities of Velen. " While this decision. The Baron was a terrible ruler and father so he can go. When. He took up residence in Crow's Perch after its previous owner, Vserad, fled to Fyke Isle with his family due to the. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt takes place in an unforgiving world where you can only choose the lesser evil. No matter what you do, it's gonna end in tears for someone. Especially with the children involved. Head north and look for Ivo on top of a rock. The hillock for which the quest is named stands just outside the village of Downwarren and is dominated by a large tree. If the werewolf is not taken out quickly, it will regenerate its health when it glows red. I've played through the game like 4 times and always been under the impression that the spirit was just some old spirit of someone who. Did they patch the Whispering Hillock 3rd ending? (Witcher 3 game) Spoilers? I guess if people haven't played it yet. Use Igni to temporarily get rid. Gallery [] Whispering Hillock is killed. This book tells a fairy tale of witches, presumably the. So, a long time ago I'd read that if you go and meet the spirit in the tree prior to activating any quest related to it, it will have an effect on the whole thing with the Baron, his wife and the Crones. Tamara was born around the year 1253 as the first child to Philip Strenger, a soldier, and Anna Strenger. I even went a far as using ddu cuz I thought it was a driver issue. Silbe 8 years ago #1. Or you can also do it because the Crones. Out in the bog, by where we dig peat, there's a beast what[sic] feeds on men and spurts out deadly mists all around itself. Part of a series of quests, The Whispering Hillock puts the player in a. Whispering Hillock bug. You'll want to kill the Whispering Hillock during this quest to get the good ending in Family Matters. For The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Whispering hillock (Spoilers)" - Page 2. As for the kids who says they actually survive. 2. Killing the Tree Spirit is the best choice. She who knows is consistent with this, and wants people to stay away from her heart, and not to actually find or face her as shown with how paranoid she was concerning Geralt. Or free it? Played through this game back in the day many times. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt > General Discussions > Topic Details. Was with her for over 10 years without marriage or makin the babies and then left her to be shamed by the village while he moved on and started a family elsewhere. Be aware that this video contains heavy SPOILERS. Main Walkthrough Location: Velen - The Whispering Hillock Prerequisites: Proceed to Downwarren during Ladies of the Wood Suggested Level: 5 Reward: XP - You won’t get. 4. Same thing happen for me. Read m. Once all three items are collected Geralt will have to pierce the spirits heart thus releasing it and taking control of the horse. The Whispering Hillock should be given the deploy ability Unseen Elder currently has. A video guide showing how to complete the quest, The Whispering Hillock on The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Important: if the first part of the quest isn't completed by the time Ghosts of the Past is started, it will not be available until after Ghosts of the Past is finished. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. 19. The Whispering Hillock Phillip Strenger - better known as the Bloody Baron - is far from being the most likable of The Witcher 3 's cast of characters, but he's certainly one of the most tragic. Precious Cargo Witcher 3 Walkthrough & Best Choices Explained. Kill the spirit, justify it as geralt thinking that he could save the kids or that he simply did not believe the spirit. Ancient Oak is a location accessible by fast travel in Velen. 4. Examine the painting to your left. As other such creatures, they are hardly hurt by steel but very vulnerable to silver. I played through Witcher 3 shortly after it released and after coming back to it all this time later, it seems there is a new option to take in the quest mentioned above. I know the book telling of the Whispering Hillock as growing mad and evil, to be turned upon by it's three children. The quest triggers when you reach the hillock and voice tells you to leave. The Whispering Hillock; The Witchers' Forge; Thou Shalt Not Pass; Trail of Echoes; Twisted Firestarter; W Warehouse of Woe; Where. 1) Kill the spirit ・・・ Children in the village all die as a. The war orphans that gather in Crookback Bog haven’t a chance of salvation. My outcome was a little odd so I was wondering if anyone else ran into this. , Jon Ryan , +35. . He never intended to. Spacedad_93. The issue still going after meet her, can only hear geralds voice till the quest ends. You could also circumvent the bug altogether by helping the Willock and releasing its spirit. However, she soon. The Crones are not done causing misery. 12 Entrance into cave Witcher's grave. The Whispering Hillock Help! Which one do you think is the lesser evil? Its my first playthrough and I'm having trouble which option should I choose to save, the 5 children or the village?. TL;DR version: Yes, he prefers to lift curses, but he rarely gets paid to do it. Before the war, the inhabitants of this village were known for their. GameSpot Expert Reviews. Whispering Hillock alternative approach . If you go to Crookback Bog and do everything up to the point where you help Johnny get his voice back, then go to the Whispering Hillock and free the Tree Spirit before returning to follow Johnny back to the Bog and meet the Crones, you. Boards; The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt; Best ending for the baron while sticking it to the crones! "spoilers. After their part in the main quest is done, the Baron's story becomes one of The Witcher 3's best side quests, and Geralt has to make one of the most consequential choices when deciding whether to kill or help the Whispering Hillock that the Crones send him to get rid of. " The "I at least give people a chance to defend themselves. So I haven’t done the brookback bog quests as of yet. In this quest, Geralt turns to the other possible "witch" that Hendrik's notes may have referred to in hopes of finding Ciri. Her state is determined by your choice in The Whispering Hillock. Unknown to the witcher once the ritual is completed the possessed horse will attack the people of Downwarren killing the villagers in revenge and then taking the children. The quest has three options: release, trick, or kill the spirit. Then, Unseen could be given a new ability, one befitting his lore and supporting the upcoming vampire archetype. There is a broken candlestick on the table, missing a part. I personally now see that freeing was the better option imo. -Spoke to the Ealdorman learned about the Hillock-Went back agreed to free the Spirit. He can decide to free the spirit or kill it. Kozer May 26, 2015 @ 7:24am. (About the Baron, the wife, the orphans). To read the full article by Ben Jessey, hit the link below. Freed the Whispering Hillock before starting Ladies of the Wood- The Whispering Hillock is free. How is this a western RPG ? There isn't even any cowboy hats. :D Photo 1+2: OTR. Whereas the old crones represent cruel order, and a ritualistic cycle of controlled suffering. Open Geralt's inventory and read the book The Ladies of the Wood which Keira gave to him at the end of the last quest. This is the funniest outcome I experienced in Witcher 3. This article was created by Game8's elite team of writers and gamers. freeing the spirit before the Crones ask Geralt to do the Whispering Hillock event results in Anna surviving and leading to the subplot's optimistic ("Baron. Then continue following Johnny and proceed as usuall with everything else. He met Geralt in 1272 when the witcher was tasked by the Crones to assist the ealdorman. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. On the one hand, freeing the Hillock causes the destruction of a village of crone worshippers and are generally not good people. Please help me if you know a way to fix this problem. Log in to add games to your lists. It's among the hardest decisions in The Witcher 3 , but you'll trigger this 'Blue Mountains' conclusion by going for the kill option. Just finished main story of witcher 3 and I can't believe how perfect the whole game is and also sad that it ended. Ealdorman Merchant Ladies of the Wood Return to Crookback Bog The Whispering Hillock In early gameplay videos, the village is shown to be plagued by some sort of evil. The spirit also kills the inhabitants of the town where you got the dagger. It starts once you complete another main quest called "The Nilfgaardian Connection", followed by "Witch Hunt" and "Wandering in the Dark". The quest requires Geralt to decide the fate of a spirit trapped in the roots of a large oak tree. Sci-fi. Especially in that society Luther wronged Jonna. Here's how to deal with what follows. Here's every outcome and how you can get it. Read on for information on objectives and possible rewards, as well as useful tips and strategies for completing the quest. I wonder if having the Whispering Hillock quest completed prior to tackling this quest can void the achievement. Imperial Audience - Tips And Best Answers. 0 JVGS Discord. 7. i think you have to save the. The Whispering Hillock choice. Using your Witcher Senes, follow the trail of sweets. 5. The Whispering Hillock. The crones eat children, the spirit destroys a whole village. The Whispering Hillock walkthrough. The Whispering Hillock Outcome Question *Spoilers*. I haven't gotten that far, but I read that you're supposed to go help the baron cure his wife. The Whispering Hillock. For some reason after the ealdorman , my game immediately crashes. Head northwest and find Gaspard at the top of the warehouse. There, he serves as a diversion for the Baron's men, akin to a "court jester" as per Geralt's description. Strike, counter-strike! Now, young lady, to bring the day to a close, we'll go over a few witcher's Signs. We've got you covered! This is a guide to the quest titled The Whispering Hillock from The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. The Crones, also called the Ladies of the Wood, are three witches who live in a cabin in the swamps of Velen. CryptoIf the player chose to free the spirit in The Whispering Hillock, the Orphans of Crookback Bog will be saved by the spirit, but Anna will be cursed and turned into a water hag by the Crones. You free the Spirit after it agrees to save the children in Crookback Bog, and it then ravages Downwarren. Cheats. Read up that it was part of another quest and so I said I would think about freeing it or not. And yes saving innocent children does sound morally good but only if you know the two outcomes. A quest in The Witcher 3 that tasks Geralt with saving a spirit trapped in a tree. Additionally, they did it to protect Velen, as is written in the book She Who Knows. This quest is right up there with the whispering hillock for me in terms of its moral dilemma. Head to Downwarren where, depending on your choice during The Whispering Hillock, the village will either be. The book she who knows said who the spirit in the whispering hillock was. Time to start heading towards this Whispering Hillock. To this day it lies trapped beneath the Whispering Hillock, where it thrashes about in powerless rage. The Whispering Hillock;[Witcher 3][PS4] PSA: How I finally prevented the audio bug triggered during The Whispering Hillock. Once you make it back you're given one last chance to reconsider your choice before performing the ritual, either by tricking the spirit or outright killing it. Read on for information on objectives and possible rewards, as well as useful tips and strategies for completing the quest. The Ancient Oak is a centuries old oak tree growing on a small hill, under which lies a system of caves that is the resting place of the Ghost in the Tree. Basically the spirit went crazy and started killing people so the crones, who are her (it's supposed to be a woman) daughters, imprisoned her there. She and Dandelion started seeing each other but she felt he needed more discipline in his life. Follow the road east to get to the witch's hut. There will be no fight, the tree dies, and the quest completes. Before the war, the inhabitants of this village were known for their intricate lacemaking and artisanal smithery. Ancient Oak is a tree located south of Downwarren in Velen. If you freed the spirit you will have to continue on to the next objectives. To this day it lies trapped beneath the Whispering Hillock, where it thrashes about in powerless rage. The Whispering Hillock Outcome Question *Spoilers*. Which gives us 3 endings indeed : go to the crones, kill spirit, children are eaten, Anna is crazy, village is ok. (obviously imo) epicroto • 1 hr. . Choices matter, but that doesn't mean you'll necessarily have any good choices. IDK what your definition of "near" is, but yes there is one in the general area. I wish you could side with the Whispering Hillock and not have the Baron and his wife die. There are two most common ways to aquire lycanthropy: the first one through a curse and the second is to simply have a werewolf parent. No battle and the quest completes. Gaeten. First you must unload an earlier save, speak to the Willock > decide to help it > gather the requested items > return to the Willock > proceed with the instructions and then instead of releasing the spirit, you can kill it instantly. The tree spirit is not "evil. . When speaking to the Crones, tell. Most of the time they communicate through an enchanted tapestry and a. Contents The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Skyrim, for example, still has discussions regarding who you chose to support during the Civil War and decisions regarding Paarthurnax. This ealdorman oversaw the village of Downwarren in Velen. After Geralt informs Keira. . Follow the trail. Don't. Whereas the old crones represent cruel order, and a ritualistic cycle of controlled suffering. "Not too long ago the areas around peasant hamlets were chock full of guardian spirits. You kill the spirit, the orphans are all doomed, Anna goes mad, Bloody Baron hopes to cure her and lives. This page covers the decisions you have to make during The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and the way they impact the main story. A main quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt where Geralt must decide the fate of a spirit trapped in a tree. Whispering hillock before met the Baron or the orphans. In order to find more information about Ciri, you have been sent to Downwarren to perform a task for the Crones of Crookback Bog. Muscle Memory. When you arrive, take a look around town. Onwards to The Whispering Hillock, or back to The Witcher 3: Act One - Velen. For The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Whispering hillock before met the Baron or the orphans". Head northwest up the incline and defeat the werewolf. Here are some of the biggest ending variations in The Witcher 3, as well as some dedicated guides for other pivotal choices you'll have to make throughout the game. The Baron leaves, taking her to a healer. You can't trust. Game keeps crashing during The Whispering Hillock quest. Ye must go there. Choice and CONSEQUENCES - "The Whispering Hillock" quest: Geralt frees the spirit beaneth the tree (Hillock saves the orphans in the bog escape) - CUTSCENES. :D Photo 1+2: OTR. Hi everyone! One of my favourite things about games with nuanced choices is the discussion that some of these choices can lead to. It could very well be the last main quest players experience in Velen, and it features several memorable. Note: this quest will fail if not completed before starting The Isle of Mists. I just stumbled on a bug where you have to calm a horse and bring it to the spirit. Because the game makes you choose, I choose the lesser evil. I think I have saved everyone. Whispering Hillock *Spoiler Alert*. ) Kids were saved (The tree spirit drops them off at an orphanage you can visit, its true to its word. In this cave you'll find a ghost, which is asking you to free it (quest: "The Whispering Hillock"). To make the. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt Act 1 – Find Johnny, Complete Family Matters, Kill the Basilisk. To get started. Take down this adversary and then strike the roots. Killed the Whispering Hillock- The Whispering Hillock died, Baron and Anna will live, the orphans will die, and Downwarren will be safe. The tapestry withholds information about Ciri until Geralt defeats a spirit known as the Whispering Hillock. I played it two times. Try adjusting your system speaker settings (eg stereo instead of 4. To this very day it is bound to The Whispering Hillock, where it wanders about in a helpless rage. Location of the Ghost in. I went back to the tree and saved it instead. To complete it you must reach the cave (M9,8) and talk with the ghost. Made them from dirt and the crones killed her because she went crazy and was going to destroy velen. I don't want the kids to get eaten, but I don't want to release the tree spirit cause there is a good chance its evil. Macintosh Nintendo Switch PC Xbox One. The player will be given another choice. Here’s a walkthrough of Ladies. 5K views 1 year ago. The Mother, She-Who-Knows, the Lady of the Wood, came here from a faraway land and, since she suffered terribly from loneliness, she made three daughters out of dirt and water. Okay, I have no idea what to do anymore. If not mistaken, attempting to free the spirit before getting the quest from the Crones kill the Hillock means the children are safe and sound w/ Nanny. You free the Spirit after it agrees to save the children in Crookback Bog, and it then ravages Downwarren. Here are a few of the most vital. Everyone is. The choice affects the outcome of the main quest \"Ladies of the Wood\" and the side quest \"Return to Crookback Bog\". This quest and the one proceeding it were heavily featured in the first series of the TV adaption of the Witcher. Witcher 3 Whispering Hillock choices . Ladies of the Wood Tips and Strategies Use Aard or a Crossbolt on the Harpies. The Witcher 3 」 with us! When reporting a problem, please be as specific as possible in. Part of a series of quests, The Whispering Hillock puts the player in a. It can either be triggered as the main quest while progressing through the Ladies of the Wood main quest or can be accidentally run into if you are. Geralt is trying to find a lead on Ciri 's friend Dandelion, so the obvious trail is of the women Dandelion has romanced around Novigrad. News. Sometimes these quests even manage to offer choices to the player that can have lasting effects on the characters involved and The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt as a whole. First off, I ran into the creepy tree when I was adventuring. This takes the form of both hyperbole -. Both are super duper evil powers. Head to Hierarch Square where you'll be treated to a cutscene that introduces Caleb Menge, the commander of the Temple Guard and leader of the witch hunters, as he proceeds to burn Felicia Cori and the doppler Chappelle at the stake. Playthrough of The Witcher 3 Wild Hunt: The Whispering Hillock quest @Qtekkers . Baron and Anna both die but the orphan kids get set free away from the Crones. May 27, 2015. There's a contract you can pick up in the village of Downwarren for it or you can do it on your own by going there. During the Whsipering Hillock part of the questchain, Geraly will have a decision to make, which will come back to haunt the bloody baron in one way or another. Love to experience a cool story section and then go back and see pieces of it that were always there, but with new context. In this video I lay out the argument for why you should kill the spirit in the ques. 5: Talk to the Skellige woman found near the beach during the day. Firstly I want to say that I knew nothing of the consequences of killing the tree. atiggerx33 8 years ago #1. "Information, "After" Whispering Hillock (Spoiler) Won’t discuss moral issues or is the spirit good or bad just. Spoiler alert for Witcher 3 quest. As you explore the hillock with your witcher senses, you'll. This page lists all the secondary quests in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, for more details see The Witcher 3 secondary quests. During the quest Ladies of the Wood, you'll learn that there's an ancient power living under a giant tree on the Whispering Hillock. Family Matters is a main quest in The Witcher 3 that helps Geralt find out where and with who Ciri went with after the quest. Whispering Hillock spoilers. leave and go do the Whispering Hillock thing and free the Tree Spirit. Ultimately she started to go mad and started causing massacres so the Crones had to kill her and bind her spirit beneath the whispering hillock, which caused an enormous tree to grow and feed the people. Which choice should I make in The Whispering Hillock mission, and why? The Witcher 3 I’m aware of the consequences of both choices, which is why I am struggling to make the. HOWEVER, the children do NOT show up in the city orphanage later. You free the spirit, the orphans are saved, Anna. Boards. If the devs want to impose their authority, maybe they shouldve made it clearer in the game. The Crones went against her as she went crazy with power. There is no right choice. Black Beauty is the name of the Ghost in the Tree's new body after transferring their soul over to a black horse if Geralt chose to free them. The Whispering Hillock Walkthrough and Best Choice. Show up, talk to Whispess, and during that conversation, as long as she doesn't get pissed at Anna, you will get the ending where the Baron and Anna go off to a healer with Anna alive as an old woman, not a hag. bad endings for. Freed the tree spirit, saved the orphans and after that liberated Anna I think. Demosthenes424 Feb 3 @ 3:37am. I think I chose the best one, though. The Witcher is a critically acclaimed fantasy book series created by Andrzej Sapkowski.